School-Live! and the Mystery of Megu-nee

megu-nee, megumi sakura, megunee is dead in gakkou gurashi, megu-nee is already dead in school-live!, school live megu-nee, gakkou gurashi

“Strange friend, past, present, and to be;

Love deeplier, darklier understood;

Behold, I dream a dream of good,

And mingle all the world with thee.”

– In Memoriam A.H.H., Alfred, Lord Tennyson

Little is revealed of Yuki Takeya in the immediate aftermath.

While School-Live! is never shown from her viewpoint, Yuki’s attendance is incredibly important to the series’ direction. When Yuki is present, everything is different from the flow of conversation between girls to the visual look and style. In it’s premiere, School-Live! spent almost the entirety of the episode in blissful ignorance alongside Yuki, with small hints leaving a breadcrumb trail leading up to the last-minute reveal. From this point on, we know that Yuki’s mind has broken, and any narration or point of view from her perspective is compromised.

megunee and yuki, yuki takeya, megumi sakura, gakkou gurashi, megunee and yuki on the school rooftop, school-live! yuki

However, as School-Live! eschews telling the story through any one character – even when episodes focus on a specific individual – the importance of just how much is compromised can often be forgotten as a viewer attempts to put together the pieces. Yuki’s mind is shattered, but the extent of her psychological damage is unknown. The girls themselves admit this in a conversation about Yuki, when Miki asks if they should do something about her delusions.

Following the series fourth episode, the figurative curtain is pulled back a bit more, revealing the depth of Yuki’s broken psyche. Their cheerful teacher Megu-nee allows Kurumi to drive her car for no logical reason, and the keys are never touched by Megu-nee herself. Additionally Megu-nee’s timely appearance in the vehicle’s backseat in spite of her absence in Kurumi’s mad dash to reach the car give the viewer a key piece of the puzzle.

Yuki is the only person who can “see” Megu-nee, because Megu-nee is already dead.

megunee in the teacher's loungue, gakkou gurashi teacher's lounge, megumi sakura megunee, megunee school-live!,

This in and of itself is another “soft reveal” of sorts. Combined with an introduction to Miki Naoki’s story in Episode 4, an astute viewer can begin to piece together a timeline. Yuki is purposefully shown as distraught upon seeing the extent of the zombie infestation, as well as Kurumi killing their classmate; however, the viewer has no way of knowing if that is the moment that her mind breaks, or if something worse was the cause. All the viewer does know, is that at some point between writing her letter in the teacher’s lounge and magically appearing in the backseat of her own car, Megumi Sakura died.

School-Live! never breaks its own rules. Examining previous episodes after watching the fourth will only reveal that the clues were already there – additionally, smaller things fall into place, like why Taroumaru is afraid of Miki. Yuki always talks to Megu-nee first, before the others do, with the exception of choice flashbacks shown in Episode Three. Often Yuki will restate what Megu-nee says, effectively translating it to the others. Additionally, Miki is the most uncomfortable when “Megu-nee” is present due to her joining the group later in the timeline, when Megu-nee had already died.

megunee and yuki, megunee with yuki, yuki takeya, megumi sakura, gakkou gurashi megunee and yuki in the library

“It’s okay. Everyone cares about you. They’re all trying to save you. As long as you have them, you don’t need to worry about any ghost.”

– Megumi Sakura (Megu-nee) to Yuki Takeya, School-Live!, Episode 2

While Yuki is indubitably delusional, it’s always Megu-nee who stops her from doing something completely rash, or reminding her how valuable her friends are. Megu-nee is the part of Yuki’s brain that recognizes that there is still something awful happening, even if the rest of her mind refuses to realize it.

6 comments

  1. Holy cow, I never guessed that she was a split personality of yuki’s :0 . I’m gonna have to go re watch the series now haha. I love how layered and deep the series is – appearances definitely aren’t everything here. Probs my favourite this season

    1. Either a split personality or more likely just a defense mechanism. Yuki was already obviously affected after she watched Kurumi kill her zombified love interest. Megu-nee was alive at that point and actively protecting her. I think that when Yuki’s mind broke, part of it remained aware of the situation, but is largely suppressed by her inability to cope. Therefore, this defense against what is happening takes the form of Megu-nee because her teacher was the last living authority figure present. “Megu-nee” is always giving Yuki useful advice or reminding her of how her friends are there to protect her/keep her safe. Additionally “Megu-nee” also assumes authority when Yuki’s life is in immediate danger, allowing Yuki to remain safe while maintaining the illusion.

      Yeah, the series is cleverly directed. I’m really enjoying it.

  2. Great points! I felt pretty sure from episode 2 and 3 that Megu–nee was already passed on and only in Yuki’s head, but this latest episode really confirmed it for reasons you pointed out!

    This is such an excellent show, wow!😀

    1. I was honestly impressed when I went back and realized that the series never breaks its own rules when dealing with “Megu-nee.” This also allows for us to further establish timelines by paying attention to who talks to the teacher and when.

  3. Yep, I think Megumi- Sensei only exist in the mind of Yuki, but then again, I’m looking at Megumi- Sensei as a ghost, protecting Yuki, well its just me of course.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s