Who is Diana Cavendish?
What makes her, Diana Cavendish?
Take away the prestige attached to her recognizable family name and the simpering sidekicks. Treat her like any other student at Luna Nova, albeit with similar magical talent but less training. Would she inevitably rise to the top of the school or would she become just another student as magic continues to fade from existence?
If she isn’t the last hope of Luna Nova and the art of magic, then just who is Diana Cavendish?
Diana was born with everything — a well-known prominent family, prodigious talent, good looks, the best education, and nearly all of the resources to become the best witch of her generation. She took all of these resources and used them to surpass everyone’s expectations.
She’s also completely and utterly bored.
Not only is Diana often a foil for Luna Nova’s resident dunce, Akko Kagari, she’s also the divergent path. Nestled in the same audience, squirming in nervous excitement with the same breathless anticipation as young Akko was a young Diana, equally charmed by Shiny Chariot’s traveling magic show. Chariot inspired both witches, but only Diana had the resources at that age to pursue magic.
When she meets Akko face to face, Diana is already cold and hardened. Years of arduous study have placed her on a pedestal built not only from her peers but her elders and superiors. She’s already saved the school on numerous occasions, to the point where the faculty is now counting on her to become the savior of Luna Nova — and magic as an art.
Yet, the one thing Diana wasn’t seemingly predestined for is the revival of magic itself, despite what the Luna Nova faculty and student body believe.
Little Witch Academia‘s twelfth episode places Akko in the body of Diana. A magic mirror catches Akko in a moment of self-doubt and transforms her to look like Diana.
From that point until Akko as Diana is asked to perform magic, and fails, Akko is forced to see just the difficulties of Diana’s life. Around every corner, there’s another person who needs something from Diana or someone asking Diana to fix their problems. Diana helps a multitude of people, some of whom are her own teachers, with a variety of things on a daily basis. This only adds to Diana’s isolation.
Part of the privilege of being Diana Cavendish means that people automatically take her seriously, giving her the benefit of the doubt — something that Akko is obviously unused to, even though she spends very little time as Diana. The tradeoff is that Diana is constantly being petitioned by anyone and everyone for her help. As Akko tries to get out of everyone’s way while stuck in Diana’s body, people continue to seek her out, leaving Akko no chance to escape the charade.
A cursory look into Diana’s living arrangements reveals that she is purposefully separated from her suite-mates, Hanna and Barbara. Whether this is of Diana’s own wishes — or one more unintended result of Hanna and Barbara’s hero worship, insisting that Diana have a space all to herself as another nod to Diana’s lofty social standing — is unknown. However, it firmly divides Diana from her so-called friends.
Visual framing also serves to isolate Diana. She is placed at the forefront of nearly all of her scenes — except those where she is truly alone — with Hanna and Barbara flanking her on either side.
Even when she’s not in the center, she still commands the attention of the viewer, thanks to more flanking assists from Hanna and Barbara.
Framing ensures that the eye is naturally drawn to Diana. Diana’s character design, posture, and positioning further establish her social station.
By contrast, Akko is only shown in this position a few times — when it’s necessary for her to take the lead and draw upon magic stored within the Shiny Rod. In these scenes she becomes almost a conduit for magic, drawing on Lotte and Sucy’s powers like Usagi Tsukino relying on her sailor scouts in Sailor Moon.
All other times, Akko is the beating heart of the trio but is anything but on a pedestal. This too is reinforced visually. Like the scenes where she becomes a center, Akko is visibly embraced and surrounded by friends rather than placed above them.
When Akko strikes out alone, her friends discover her plot and vow to help her. When Diana strikes out alone, her acquaintances either don’t pry — perhaps because they see Diana as above their station — or feel too inferior to help. Compare their magical displays in Episode 13’s Samhain Festival — Akko is assisted by her friends while Hanna and Barbara leave Diana’s side so Diana can complete the water summoning.
At the end of it all, Diana is rewarded with the title of Moonlit Witch, despite knowing that Akko should have been in contention at the very least. Disqualified due to rule-breaking, Akko is once again pushed out of the picture for Diana to receive more praise that she feels like she doesn’t deserve. The Luna Nova Samhain Festival is the papilliodya chrysalises situation on a far greater scale — Akko succeeds but Diana receives the accolades or award.
Here, Little Witch Academia strikes the perfect note for both Akko and Diana. Diana was right to doubt Akko’s words and motives due to Akko’s general lack of follow-through. Yet Akko is instrumental in reminding Diana of why Diana decided to put all of her effort — immense talent or no — into magic. They need each other to push one another to greater heights. Diana reiterates that Akko needs diligence and practice, not just passion, while Akko reminds Diana of the latent passion that inspired her in the first place, the passion that made her into the Diana Cavendish we know.
“Diana was right to doubt Akko’s words and motives due to Akko’s general lack of follow-through.”
Here’s where I disagree. I don’t think she was right at all. I think she was judgmental, assuming the worst out of superficial knowledge of Akko and her situation. The people who really knew Akko never doubted her. And I think the best scene was when Lotte of all people told Diana she was talking out of… well, her behind, so to speak.
In any case, this is a good chance for Diana to re-evaluate not just her view on Akko but herself.
Maybe I’m just an overly harsh person. Here’s the way I see it. Diana is tasked with overseeing the festival. Every time she runs into Akko, Akko is trying to do things that vastly exceed her currently ability with little to no actual follow-through. Now Akko is part of a festival that Diana is helping run, and Akko is once again dissatisfied with the role she was given and trying to use shortcuts to get ahead.
Diana isn’t going out of her way to undermine Akko (like Hanna and Barbara do), especially since she knows Akko is capable when she tries (like the papilliodya incident). The problem is that Diana, unlike Ursula, Sucy, Lotte, or us as the audience, doesn’t see how hard Akko has been working since she first saw the Fountain of Polaris. She only sees Akko overreaching, again.
If she had the knowledge of say, Professor Finneran, who I do this is overly judgmental and only cares about appearances, then I would come down harder on Diana. Going forward, if Diana reacts in a similar fashion to Akko in the series, I’ll be harsher on her. But, looking at how much information she had to go on in Episodes 12 and 13 in addition to what she knows of Akko’s character (a dreamer without followthrough who takes shortcuts) I’m not going to condemn Diana for her response to Akko.
I agree with this wholeheartedly.
You said it yourself, unlike most people in Luna Nova, she knew what Akko is capable of when she tries (like the papilliodya incident) so why not take the time to really see what makes Akko Akko? I can’t excuse her attitude on the fact she didn’t know Akko better. All the opposite, being quick to judge with superficial impressions is a problem in and of itself.
Her judgmental nature parallels her tendency to think she knows better, and her misguided belief that she can do everything alone.
Honestly, her character arc should have started after episode 2. But back then she brushed the whole thing off and deluded herself into thinking there was nothing wrong. Dismissing Akko as an idiot might have been part of her unconscious attempt to put the matter aside so she wouldn’t have to re-evaluate herself and see she’s not as perfect as she thinks.
Episode 13 feels somewhat redundant. Or it’s the writer basically saying Diana was so blind by her pride she needed something of this scale to stop denying the obvious.
Either way, the destination is the same.
That was really interesting. I’ve always liked how the story never framed Diana as a stereotypical bully character and treated her as an actual person outside of her interactions with Akko. She comes off as cold and haughty sometimes, but she’s actually talented and clearly not a bad person. She just needs to be a little more like Akko (and Akko needs to be a little more like Diana).
The themes in LWA aren’t so far divorced from KLK. Like Satsuki, Diana’s life is consumed by duty. And like Ryouko, Akko is full of passion.
The second will help redeem the first. I think that will be part of the second season, and we will see Diana become a helper and even co-hero for Akko. Eventually. It’s likely the quest to restore magic to the world will make them opponents, for a time. Most likely through the devious doings of either or both of Woodward and Croix.
This was an interesting look at framing! I enjoyed that you discussed both the visual framing as well as the way that each character is perceived by those around them and the audience. It’s an interesting realization when a character is revealed to be far different than the audience thought simply by seeing events from another perspective.
Today is 13 February 2023 , 1:27pm from Malaysia . I still miss Little Witch Academia .